Divergent Ethical Perspectives on the Duty-to-Warn Principle With HIV Patients
Huprich, Steven K.
Fuller, Kristi M.
Schneider, Robert B.
Ethics and Behavior 2003; 13(3): 263-278
This article presents the case of an HIV-positive client who reported having sexual relations with an unknowing partner. The issue raised is whether the therapist was required to warn the unknowing partner, similar to the Tarasoff mandate that is imposed on therapists. The case is analyzed from an ethical framework similar to that presented by Beauchamp and Childress (1994). Two opinions are presented, each leading to different conclusions about whether the therapist should inform the unknowing partner. It is concluded that although such analysis is valuable in aiding the therapist in his or her decision-making process, no clear professional standard for the management of the problem is evident.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Should healthcare providers have a duty to warn family members of individuals with an HNPCC-causing mutation? A survey of patients from the Ontario Familial Colon Cancer Registry Kohut, Kelly; Manno, Michael; Gallinger, Steven; Esplen, Mary Jane (2007-06)
Ethical and Legal Implications of Cancer Genetic Testing: Do Physicians Have a Duty to Warn Patients' Relatives About Possible Genetic Risks? Storm, Courtney; Agarwal, Rinki; Offit, Kenneth (2008-09)This vignette raises questions about the extent of physicians' obligations to warn relatives of a patient about a hereditary cancer risk.