Managing Chronic Disease: Evidence-Based Medicine or Patient Centred Medicine?
Vlieland, Thea P.M. Vliet
Health Care Analysis: An International Journal of Health Care Philosophy and Policy 2002; 10(3): 289-298
Chronic diseases are recognized as a leading cause of mortality, morbidity, health care utilization and cost. A constant tailoring of care to the actual needs of individual patients, complexity and long duration are the distinguishing features of chronic disease management. Given the rapid development and high use of services providing complex management, the number of controlled clinical trials in this field is limited. The information from the few available controlled clinical trials may be difficult to interpret, mainly due to a large variety in the interventions being studied, differences in 'control treatments' and a confined set of outcome measures that are used. The ethical issue with this observation is, that in the absence of randomised clinical trial information on clinical effectiveness and in consequence of the lack of additional data that are crucial for therapeutic decisions in the process of caring, specific patient groups, such as patients with chronic diseases, may become disadvantaged. The scarcity and incompleteness of controlled trial information can partly be explained by difficulties in conducting this type of research in the field of chronic disease management. To avoid that patients with chronic diseases become disadvantaged, the use of alternative designs such as observational studies to evaluate chronic disease management must be accepted and supported. Moreover, in chronic disease management the process of caring needs to emphasized and appraised appropriately. For that purpose, new measurement methods, focussing on concepts of caring that are not included in the majority of current clinical trials, need to be developed.
Caring; Clinical Trials; Controlled Clinical Trials; Disease; Evidence-Based Medicine; Health; Health Care; Medicine; Methods; Morbidity; Mortality; Patients; Research; Scarcity; Quality of Health Care; Human Experimentation Policy Guidelines / Institutional Review Boards; Health Care for Particular Diseases or Groups;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Doing the Right Thing Right: Is Evidence-Based Medicine the Answer? Review of EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE: HOW to PRACTICE and TEACH EBM, by D.L. Sackett, W.S. Richardson, W. Rosenberg and R.B. Haynes; and EVIDENCE-BASED HEALTHCARE: HOW to MAKE HEALTH POLICY and MANAGEMENT DECISIONS, by J.A. Muir Gray) Wallace, Eleanor Z.; Leipzig, Rosanne M. (1997-07-01)
Can Evidence-Based Medicine Implicitly Rely on Current Concepts of Disease or Does It Have to Develop Its Own Definition? Gerber, Andreas; Hentzelt, Frieder; Lauterbach, Karl W. (2007-07)Decisions in healthcare are made against the background of cultural and philosophical definitions of disease, sickness and illness. These concepts or definitions affect both health policy (macro level) and research (meso ...