Asperger Syndrome and the Supposed Obligation Not to Bring Disabled Lives Into the World
Journal of medical ethics 2010 Sep; 36(9): 521-4
Asperger syndrome (AS) is an autistic spectrum condition that shares the range of social impairments associated with classic autism widely regarded as disabling, while also often giving rise to high levels of ability in areas such as maths, science, engineering and music. The nature of this striking duality of disability and ability is examined, along with its implications for our thinking about disability and the relevance of levels and kinds of disability to reproductive choices. In particular, it may be seen as posing a challenge to John Harris's influential position in reproductive ethics relating to disability. The paper argues that if, as Harris maintains, there is a quite general moral obligation to avoid bringing disabled lives into the world regardless of the level of disability, then AS must be seen as having a strong claim to be exempt from such an obligation. However, a broader critique of Harris's position leads to the conclusion that, in fact, this putative obligation does not exist.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Olsen, J. Mark (2006-09)Within both popular and academic literature, concerns have been expressed about the implications of antidepressant use on character development. In this paper, I identify specific versions of these worries and argue that ...
At Home With Down Syndrome Review of Gifts: Mothers Reflect on How Children With Down Syndrome Enrich Their Lives Edited by Kathryn Lynard Soper; Count Us In: Growing Up With Down Syndrome by Jason Kingsley and Mitchell Levitz; Chicken Soup For the Soul: Children With Special Needs Edited by Jack Canfield, Et Al; Common Threads: Celebrating Life With Down Syndrome by Cynthia S. Kidder and Brian Skotko; You Will Dream New Dreams: Inspiring Personal Stories by Parents of Children With Disabilities Edited by Stanley D. Klein and Kim Schive; Road Map to Holland: How I Found My Way Through My Son's First Two Years With Down Syndrome by Jennifer Graf Groneberg Nicol, Caitrin (2008-03)