Do Strong Value-Based Attitudes Influence Estimations of Future Events?
Journal of medical ethics 2010 Apr; 36(4): 255-6
The purpose of the present study was to examine whether or not strong values might influence physicians' estimations of future events. In an empirical study about physicians' attitudes towards physician assisted suicide (PAS) we asked about the physicians' main reasons for being pro, doubtful or contra PAS and also asked them to estimate what would happen with patients' trust if PAS were to be legally accepted in Swedish society. Finally we asked the physicians about their own trust in healthcare in the event of PAS being legally accepted. We found that in contrast to those who were pro PAS and doubtful, the group who were against PAS did not discriminate between their own opinion and their estimation of what they thought might happen with patients' trust in the future. Against the backdrop of the present study, we present a hypothesis maintaining that feeling strongly against controversial medical procedures is associated with being inclined to let one's own beliefs influence our capacity to interpret and estimate empirical results. We think this hypothesis merits closer examination.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
When Enough Is Enough; Terminating Life-Sustaining Treatment at the Patient's Request: A Survey of Attitudes Among Swedish Physicians and the General Public Lindblad, Anna; Juth, Niklas; Fürst, Carl Johan; Lynöe, Niels (2010-05)OBJECTIVES: To explore attitudes and reasoning among Swedish physicians and the general public regarding the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment at a competent patient's request. DESIGN: A vignette-based postal ...
Juth, Niklas; Tillberg, Therése; Lynöe, Niels (2011-08)The aim of this pilot study was to develop a realistic clinical case for identifying Knobe's asymmetric effect, ie, the tendency to ascribe intentions to a larger extent when an act is considered wrong, as well as to compare ...
Lynöe, Niels; Juth, Niklas; Helgesson, Gert (2010-02)In a Swedish setting physicians are unlikely to give explicitly paternalistic reasons when asked about their attitudes towards patients' involvement in decision-making. There is considerable risk that they will disguise ...