Assessing the Public's Views in Research Ethics Controversies: Deliberative Democracy and Bioethics as Natural Allies
Kim, Scott Y.H.
Wall, Ian F.
De Vries, Raymond
Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 2009 December; 4(4): 3-16
In a liberal democracy, policy decisions regarding ethical controversies, including those in research ethics, should incorporate the opinions of its citizens. Eliciting informed and well-considered ethical opinions can be challenging. The issues may not be widely familiar and they may involve complex scientific, legal, historical, and ethical dimensions. Traditional surveys risk eliciting superficial and uninformed opinions that may be of dubious quality for policy formation. We argue that the theory and practice of deliberative democracy (DD) is especially useful in overcoming such inadequacies. We explain DD theory and practice, discuss the rationale for using DD methods in research ethics, and illustrate in depth the use of a DD method for a longstanding research ethics controversy involving research based on surrogate consent. The potential pitfalls of DD and the means of minimizing them as well as future research directions are also discussed.
Permanent LinkFind in a Library
Full Text from Publisher
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Assessing the Quality of Democratic Deliberation: A Case Study of Public Deliberation on the Ethics of Surrogate Consent for Research De Vries, Raymond; Stanczyk, Aimee; Wall, Ian F; Uhlmann, Rebecca; Damschroder, Laura J; Kim, Scott Y (2010-06)"Deliberative democracy" is an increasingly popular method for soliciting public input on health care policies. There are a number of ways of organizing deliberative democracy (DD) sessions, but they generally involve ...
Kim, Scott Y H; Uhlmann, Rebecca A; Appelbaum, Paul S; Knopman, David S; Kim, H Myra; Damschroder, Laura; Beattie, Elizabeth; Struble, Laura; De Vries, Raymond (2010-07)Research involving incapacitated persons with dementia entails complex scientific, legal, and ethical issues, making traditional surveys of layperson views on the ethics of such research challenging. We therefore assessed ...