Appropriate Methodologies for Empirical Bioethics: It's All Relative
Bioethics 2009 May; 23(4): 249-258
In this article we distinguish between philosophical bioethics (PB), descriptive policy orientated bioethics (DPOB) and normative policy oriented bioethics (NPOB). We argue that finding an appropriate methodology for combining empirical data and moral theory depends on what the aims of the research endeavour are, and that, for the most part, this combination is only required for NPOB. After briefly discussing the debate around the is/ought problem, and suggesting that both sides of this debate are misunderstanding one another (i.e. one side treats it as a conceptual problem, whilst the other treats it as an empirical claim), we outline and defend a methodological approach to NPOB based on work we have carried out on a project exploring the normative foundations of paternal rights and responsibilities. We suggest that given the prominent role already played by moral intuition in moral theory, one appropriate way to integrate empirical data and philosophical bioethics is to utilize empirically gathered lay intuition as the foundation for ethical reasoning in NPOB. The method we propose involves a modification of a long-established tradition on non-intervention in qualitative data gathering, combined with a form of reflective equilibrium where the demands of theory and data are given equal weight and a pragmatic compromise reached.
Permanent LinkFind in a Library
Full Text from Publisher
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Becoming a father/refusing fatherhood: an empirical bioethics approach to paternal responsibilities and rights Ives, Jonathan; Draper, Heather; Pattison, Helen; Williams, Clare (2008-06)In this paper, we present the first stage of an empirical bioethics project exploring the moral sources of paternal responsibilities and rights. In doing so, we present both (1) data on men's normative constructions of ...
Ives, Jonathan; Greenfield, Sheila; Parry, Jayne M.; Draper, Heather; Gratus, Christine; Petts, Judith I.; Sorell, Tom; Wilson, Sue (2009)