`Even if You? Re Positive, You Still Have Rights Because You Are a Person? Human Rights and the Reproductive Choice of HIV-Positive Persons
Orner, Phyllis J.
Developing World Bioethics 2008 April; 8(1): 11-22
Global debates in approaches to HIV/AIDS control have recently moved away from a uniformly strong human rights-based focus. Public health utilitarianism has become increasingly important in shaping national and international policies. However, potentially contradictory imperatives may require reconciliation of individual reproductive and other human rights with public health objectives. Current reproductive health guidelines remain largely non prescriptive on the advisability of pregnancy amongst HIV-positive couples, mainly relying on effective counselling to enable autonomous decision making by clients. Yet, health care provider values and attitudes may substantially impact on the effectiveness of non prescriptive guidelines,particularly where social norms and stereotypes regarding childbearing are powerful, and where providers are subjected to dual loyalty pressures, with potentially adverse impacts on rights of service users. Data from a study of user experiences and perceptions of reproductive and HIV/AIDS services are used to illustrate a rights analysis of how reproductive health policy should integrate a rights perspective into the way services engage with HIV-positive persons and their reproductive choices. The analysis draws on recognised tools developed to evaluate health policies for their human rights impacts and on a model developed for health equity research in South Africa to argue for greater recognition of agency on the part of persons affected by HIV/AIDS in the development and content of policies on reproductive choices. We conclude by proposing strategies that are based upon a synergy between human rights and public health approaches to policy on reproductive health choices for persons with HIV/AIDS.
Aids; Attitudes; Decision Making; Guidelines; Health; Health Care; Human Rights; Public Health; Pregnancy; Research; Rights; Utilitarianism; Values; Reproduction / Reproductive Technologies; International and Political Dimensions of Biology and Medicine; Health Care Programs for Women; Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome or HIV Infection;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Policy Maker and Health Care Provider Perspectives on Reproductive Decision-Making Amongst HIV-Infected Individuals in South Africa Harries, Jane; Cooper, Diane; Myer, Landon; Bracken, Hillary; Zweigenthal, Virginia; Orner, Phyllis (2007-10)
A Qualitative Exploration of HIV-Positive Pregnant Women's Decision-Making Regarding Abortion in Cape Town, South Africa Orner, Phyllis; de Bruyn, Maria; Harries, Jane; Cooper, Diane (2010-08)HIV-positive women's abortion decisions were explored by: (i) investigating influencing factors; (ii) determining knowledge of abortion policy and public health services; and (iii) exploring abortion experiences. In-depth ...
'It Hurts, but I Don't Have a Choice, I'm Not Working and I'm Sick': Decisions and Experiences Regarding Abortion of Women Living With HIV in Cape Town, South Africa Orner, Phyllis; de Bruyn, Maria; Cooper, Diane (2011-08)Research was conducted with 36 women living with HIV in Cape Town, South Africa, regarding their decision-making about, and experiences with, abortion of unwanted pregnancies in the public health sector. Abortion intentions ...