Refining Deliberation in Bioethics
Medicine, health care, and philosophy 2009 Nov ; 12(4): 393-7
The multidisciplinary provenance of bioethics leads to a variety of discursive styles and ways of reasoning, making the discipline vulnerable to criticism and unwieldy to the setting of solid theoretical foundations. Applied ethics belongs to a group of disciplines that resort to deliberation rather than formal argumentation, therefore employing both factual and value propositions, as well as emotions, intuitions and other non logical elements. Deliberation is thus enriched to the point where ethical discourse becomes substantial rather than purely analytical. Caution must be exercised to avoid this formal permissiveness from accepting empty and incorrigible statements that are but flatus voci since they can neither be supported nor falsified. It is therefore suggested that deliberation in bioethics should comply with three sets of conditions: (1) Be understandable, truthful, honest and pertinent, as suggested by communicative ethics; (2) Allow for second order, thick judgements as suggested by pragmatism; (3) Abide by additional criteria as here proposed: Doxastic propositions should be bolstered by a cognitive element; statements should be specific and proportional to the issue at hand, and they should be arguable and coherent.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Bioética y biotecnología: lo humano entre dos paradigmas=Bioethics and biotechnology: the human between two paradigms Schramm, Fermín Roland; Lang, Miguel Kottow (2001)
Kottow, Miguel (2009-09)
Plagiarism. Document from the ethics commission of the medical school, University of Chile = En referencia al plagio intelectual. Documento de la Comisión de Etica de la Facultad de Medicina de la Universidad de Chile Rosselot Jaramillo, Eduardo; Bravo Lechat, Mireya; Kottow Lang, Miguel; Valenzuela Yuraidini, Carlos; O'Ryan Gallardo, Miguel; Thambo Becker, Sergio; Horwitz Campos, Nina; Acevedo Pérez, Irene; Rueda Castro, Laura; Sotomayor, María Angélica (2008-05)