Georgetown University LogoGeorgetown University Library LogoDigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • Georgetown College
    • Department of Philosophy
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Philosophy
    • View Item
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • Georgetown College
    • Department of Philosophy
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Philosophy
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Epistemological Hermeneutics in the Clinic

    Cover for Epistemological Hermeneutics in the Clinic
    View/Open
    View/Open: Kolmes_georgetown_0076D_14847.pdf (1.1MB) Bookview

    Creator
    Kolmes, Sara Kjellaug
    Advisor
    Kukla, Quill R
    ORCID
    0000-0003-4638-4639
    Abstract
    Sometimes, people using different epistemological strategies have to work together on a shared project. The differences between their epistemological strategies may make it difficult to share knowledge relevant to their shared goals. Especially in the context of shared projects, it is sometimes inappropriate or impractical to normatively intervene on the epistemological strategies other people are using. This might be because doing so would harm the working relationship, or because a project is time-sensitive enough that deep epistemological discussions are impossible. In this kind of case, knowledge must be 'translated' so it can be shared- knowledge justified within one epistemological system must be made intelligible in another. The parties need not agree that a particular piece of supposed knowledge is true, but they do both need to understand it in order to move forward together.
     
    This dissertation develops a roadmap for non-ideal epistemological analysis of the conversational barriers that incompatible epistemological strategies can raise to information-sharing, with clinical bioethical communication as a guiding example. I have called this strategy epistemological hermeneutics: the practice of making one’s epistemological strategy understood. Epistemological Hermeneutics allows us to learn from people who know differently than we do in real-life conversations.
     
    I take the insights from bioethicists and researchers looking at these cases to set up a framework of way that bridging an epistemological gap in conversation looks like. This project stays close to reports from doctors who encounter this kind of clinical conversation, reports from patients who believe in miracles, and descriptions (from bioethicists) of how to make this conversation go well. From analyses of successful conclusions to these conversations and attention to the specific epistemological differences between medical professionals and miracle-invoking patients, I backward-engineer a set of steps which will reliably lead a medical professional who is entirely ignorant of their patient's epistemology to be able to identify what their patient is trying to express and respond appropriately when they are facing a patient using an unfamiliar knowing-strategy.
     
    Description
    Ph.D.
    Permanent Link
    http://hdl.handle.net/10822/1062375
    Date Published
    2021
    Subject
    Clinical Bioethics; Communication; Culture; Epistemology; Religion; Medical ethics; Knowledge, Theory of; Ethics; Medical ethics; Epistemology; Ethics;
    Type
    thesis
    Publisher
    Georgetown University
    Extent
    134 leaves
    Collections
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Philosophy
    Metadata
    Show full item record

    Related items

    Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

    • Thumbnail

      The Clinic Gunman and the Victim: Abortion Fight Reflected in 2 Lives 

      Rimer, Sara (1993-03-14)
    Related Items in Google Scholar

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2023 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility
     

     

    Browse

    All of DigitalGeorgetownCommunities & CollectionsCreatorsTitlesBy Creation DateThis CollectionCreatorsTitlesBy Creation Date

    My Account

    Login

    Statistics

    View Usage Statistics

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2023 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility