Georgetown University LogoGeorgetown University Library LogoDigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • School of Continuing Studies
    • Liberal Studies
    • Liberal Studies Theses and Dissertations
    • View Item
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • School of Continuing Studies
    • Liberal Studies
    • Liberal Studies Theses and Dissertations
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    SMALL TEXTS, BIG PRESUMPTIONS: The intersection of material science and social science in the authentication of suspect Dead Sea Scrolls fragments

    Restricted Access
    View/Open
    View/Open: Loll_georgetown_0076D_15122.pdf (118MB)

    Creator
    Loll, Colette
    Advisor
    McNelis, Charles
    Abstract
    Abstract:Since 2002, many previously unknown textual fragments inscribed in Hebrew or Aramaic have surfaced on the antiquities market. Believed to be newly discovered biblical artifacts belonging to the canon of the Dead Sea Scroll Discovery, dozens have been acquired, publicly exhibited, and published by private and institutional collectors. The Museum of the Bible (MOTB) in Washington, DC, curates sixteen of these suspect fragments. Since the scholarly publication of its collection in Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection (Brill, 2016) dissenting scholars have expressed growing concern about the authenticity of the fragments in the museum's collection. This dissertation sets a foundational understanding of the problem by examining the pillars of inquiry that have historically contributed to the authentication of ancient texts and revealing the problematic subjectivity and presumption inherent to the process. It will argue that a scientific analysis, focused on material characteristics, can overcome prior disciplinary presumptions and correct the methodological failures which led to the previous conclusion of authenticity for the collection of Dead Sea Scroll fragments at the Museum of the Bible (MOTB). This research describes and summarizes the scientific analysis that led to the conclusion that the collection was comprised of modern forgeries; outlining the physical, elemental, molecular, and mineralogical analysis of the questioned scroll fragments. The resulting discourse attempts to end the conflation and confusion between claims of authenticity and actual authenticity by establishing a rigorous protocol for the scientific interrogation of purported Dead Sea Scroll fragments and identifying and avoiding the trap of presumptive attribution errors. It also explores previously neglected dimensions of human experience that provide a more nuanced picture of the prior authentication process, previously subjective, biased, and non-evidence based. Taken together, these analyses serve as a roadmap for avoiding similar methodological failures in the future.
    Description
    D.L.S.
    Permanent Link
    http://hdl.handle.net/10822/1063069
    Date Published
    2021
    Subject
    authentication; biopsychology; Dead Sea Scrolls; Museum of the Bible; textual forgery; Bible; Museum techniques�; Biblical studies; Museum studies;
    Type
    thesis
    Embargo Lift Date
    2024-02-02
    Publisher
    Georgetown University
    Extent
    223 leaves
    Collections
    • Liberal Studies Theses and Dissertations
    Metadata
    Show full item record

    Related items

    Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

    • Thumbnail

      Childhood, Suspect Classifications, and Conclusive Presumptions: Three Linked Riddles 

      Tribe, Laurence H. (1975-06)
    Related Items in Google Scholar

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2022 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility
     

     

    Browse

    All of DigitalGeorgetownCommunities & CollectionsCreatorsTitlesBy Creation DateThis CollectionCreatorsTitlesBy Creation Date

    My Account

    Login

    Statistics

    View Usage Statistics

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2022 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility