Duty to disclose what? Querying the putative obligation to return research results to participants
Journal of Medical Ethics 2008 March; 34(3): 210-213
Many research ethics guidelines now oblige researchers to offer research participants the results of research in which they participated. This practice is intended to uphold respect for persons and ensure that participants are not treated as mere means to an end. Yet some scholars have begun to question a generalised duty to disclose research results, highlighting the potential harms arising from disclosure and questioning the ethical justification for a duty to disclose, especially with respect to individual results. In support of this view, we argue that current rationales for a duty of disclosure do not form an adequate basis for an ethical imperative. We review policy guidance and scholarly commentary regarding the duty to communicate the results of biomedical, epidemiological and genetic research to research participants and show that there is wide variation in opinion regarding what should be disclosed and under what circumstance. Moreover, we argue that there is fundamental confusion about the notion of "research results," specifically regarding three core concepts: the distinction between aggregate and individual results, amongst different types of research, and across different degrees of result veracity. Even where policy guidance and scholarly commentary have been most forceful in support of an ethical imperative to disclose research results, ambiguity regarding what is to be disclosed confounds ethical action.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
When research seems like clinical care: a qualitative study of the communication of individual cancer genetic research results Miller, Fiona A.; Giacomini, Mita; Ahern, Catherine; Robert, Jason S.; de Laat, Sonya (2008-02-22)Background: Research ethicists have recently declared a new ethical imperative: that researchers should communicate the results of research to participants. For some analysts, the obligation is restricted to the communication ...
What is a meaningful result? Disclosing the results of genomic research in autism to research participants. Miller, Fiona Alice; Hayeems, Robin Zoe; Bytautas, Jessica Peace (2010-08)Developments in genomics research have been accompanied by a controversial ethical injunction: that researchers disclose individually relevant research results to research participants. With the explosion of genomic research ...