Why we are not morally required to select the best children: a response to Savulescu
Creator
Stoller, Sarah E.
Bibliographic Citation
Bioethics 2008 September; 22(7): 364-369
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to review critically Julian Savulescu's principle of 'Procreative Beneficence,' which holds that prospective parents are morally obligated to select, of the possible children they could have, those with the greatest chance of leading the best life. According to this principle, prospective parents are obliged to use the technique of pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) to select for the 'best' embryos, a decision that ought to be made based on the presence or absence of both disease traits and non-disease traits such as intelligence. While several articles have been written in response to Savulescu's principle, none has systematically explored its philosophical underpinnings to demonstrate where it breaks down. In this paper I argue that the examples that Savulescu employs to support his theory in fact fail to justify it. He presents these examples as analogous to PGD, when in fact they differ from it in subtle but morally relevant ways. Specifically, Savulescu fails to acknowledge the fact that his examples evoke deontological and virtue ethics concerns that are absent in the context of PGD. These differences turn out to be crucial, so that, in the end, the analogies bear little support for his theory. Finally, I lay out the implications of this analysis for reproductive ethics.
Permanent Link
Find Full Text at Georgetown University Library.Full Text from Publisher
http://hdl.handle.net/10822/513283
Date
2008-09Collections
Metadata
Show full item recordRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Procreative beneficence: why we should select the best children
Savulescu, Julian (2001-10) -
Why genetic testing for genes for criminality is morally required
Savulescu, Julian (2001-03) -
The moral obligation to create children with the best chance of the best life.
Savulescu, Julian; Kahane, Guy (2009-06)According to what we call the Principle of Procreative Beneficence (PB),couples who decide to have a child have a significant moral reason to select the child who, given his or her genetic endowment, can be expected to ...