Procreative reasons-relevance: on the moral significance of why we have children.
Bioethics 2009 June; 23(5): 291-299
Advances in reproductive technologies - in particular in genetic screening and selection - have occasioned renewed interest in the moral justifiability of the reasons that motivate the decision to have a child. The capacity to select for desired blood and tissue compatibilities has led to the much discussed 'saviour sibling' cases in which parents seek to 'have one child to save another'. Heightened interest in procreative reasons is to be welcomed, since it prompts a more general philosophical interrogation of the grounds for moral appraisal of reasons-to-parent, and of the extent to which such reasons are relevant to the moral assessment of procreation itself. I start by rejecting the idea that we can use a distinction between 'other-regarding' and 'future-child-regarding' reasons as a basis on which to distinguish good from bad procreative reasons. I then offer and evaluate three potential grounds for elucidating and establishing a relationship between procreative motivation and the rightness/wrongness of procreative conduct: the predictiveness, the verdictiveness, and the expressiveness of procreative reasons.
Permanent LinkFind Full Text at Georgetown University Library
Full Text from Publisher
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Levy, Neil; Lotz, Mianna (2005-06)Many people now believe that human reproductive cloning--once sufficiently safe and effective--should be permitted on the grounds that it will allow the otherwise infertile to have children that are biologically closely ...
Golombok, Susan; Schulman, Joe; Dahl, Edgar; McLean, Sheila; Doyal, Len; Lotts, Jim; Lockwood, Gillian; Bhargava, Pushpa; McMahan, Jeff; Alikani, Mina; Lotz, Mianna; Te Velde, Egbert; Savulescu, Julian (2005-03)