Georgetown University LogoGeorgetown University Library LogoDigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • Georgetown College
    • Department of Arabic and Islamic Studies
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Arabic & Islamic Studies
    • View Item
    •   DigitalGeorgetown Home
    • Georgetown University Institutional Repository
    • Georgetown College
    • Department of Arabic and Islamic Studies
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Arabic & Islamic Studies
    • View Item
    JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

    Intersections: Modernity, Gender and Qurʾanic Exegesis

    Cover for Intersections: Modernity, Gender and Qurʾanic Exegesis
    View/Open
    View/Open: Mubarak_georgetown_0076D_12739.pdf (2.1MB) Bookview

    Creator
    Mubarak, Hadia
    Advisor
    Opwis, Felicitas M.
    Abstract
    Modernity imparted a new theoretical significance to the issue of gender reform in the Muslim world. This dissertation examines the impact of modernity on the hermeneutical approaches and interpretations of three modern exegetes on significant gender issues in the Qur'an. It compares the tafsir works of Muhammad 'Abduh, Sayyid Qutb, and Muhammad al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur with those of pre-modern exegetes concerning three Qur'anic verses: 2:228, 4:3, and 4:34. These verses, among others, gained significance in modern exegetes' quest to articulate Islam's position on gender, a debate that was tied to the larger ideological question on whether or not Islam was fit for modern times. By situating the exegeses of 'Abduh, Qutb, and Ibn 'Ashur within their broader historical and intellectual contexts, this dissertation demonstrates how their tafsir on gender reflects their engagement with the broader contemporaneous debates on gender and Islam in late-nineteenth- and mid-twentieth century Egypt and Tunisia. The interpretations of all three modern exegetes evince a heightened gender-consciousness that is absent from the interpretations of pre-modern exegetes on the same verses. This underscores the particularity of an exegetical gender-consciousness to the modern period.
     
    The tension between continuity and change in modern Islamic intellectual thought demonstrates that interpretive differences between modern and pre-modern exegetes are not black and white. While 'Abduh, Qutb, and Ibn 'Ashur reach significantly new conclusions on certain verses, they also echo many of the pre-modern interpretations on gender. As such, the exegetical tradition on gender reflects a variety of interpretations that defies existing generalizations of this tradition as consistently patriarchal.
     
    While the works of all three exegetes reflect full engagement with modernity, their approaches are grounded in very different methodologies, traditions, and orientations. This dissertation argues that 'Abduh and Rida's Tafsir al-Manar and Qutb's Fi Zilal al-Qur'an both signal a departure from the classical methodologies of the pre-modern exegetical tradition, whereas Ibn 'Ashur's al-Tahrir wal-Tanwir revives the methodologies of the pre-modern, philological exegetical tradition. As such, Ibn 'Ashur represents the classical Sunni practice of renewal based on pre-existing scholarly norms.
     
    Description
    Ph.D.
    Permanent Link
    http://hdl.handle.net/10822/712424
    Date Published
    2014
    Subject
    Exegesis; Gender; Islamic Thought; Modernity; Quran; Tradition; Islam and culture; Religion; Gender Identity; Islamic culture; Religion; Gender studies;
    Type
    thesis
    Embargo Lift Date
    2017-01-08
    Publisher
    Georgetown University
    Extent
    316 leaves
    Collections
    • Graduate Theses and Dissertations - Arabic & Islamic Studies
    Metadata
    Show full item record

    Related items

    Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

    • Thumbnail

      Feminist intersections in science: race, gender and sexuality through the microscope 

      Weasel, Lisa H. (2004-01)
    Related Items in Google Scholar

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2022 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility
     

     

    Browse

    All of DigitalGeorgetownCommunities & CollectionsCreatorsTitlesBy Creation DateThis CollectionCreatorsTitlesBy Creation Date

    My Account

    Login

    Statistics

    View Usage Statistics

    Georgetown University Seal
    ©2009 - 2022 Georgetown University Library
    37th & O Streets NW
    Washington DC 20057-1174
    202.687.7385
    digitalscholarship@georgetown.edu
    Accessibility