Philosophy, Medicine and Its Technologies
Journal of Medical Ethics. 1988 Dec; 14(4): 173-178.
There is a need to bring ethics and medical practice closer together, despite the risk and problems this may involve. Deontological ethics may promote sanctity of life considerations against the quality of life considerations favoured by consequentialists or utilitarians; while talk of respect for life and the value of life may point to more qualified ethical positions. This paper argues for a respect-for-life position, dismissing a utilitarian cost-benefit outlook as too simplistic; but an unqualified fixed principles approach is also ruled out, both because of its unacceptable consequences in individual cases and also because of its reliance on the slippery slope argument which, it is argued, is logically and psychologically deficient. The case of genetic engineering provides an example in which the notion of respect may operate, but in which broad general principles also apply. A cautious conservatism towards accepted principles is recommended....
Aborted Fetuses; Abortion; Allowing to Die; Anencephaly; Autonomy; Beneficence; Bioethical Issues; Bioethics; Biomedical Technologies; Congenital Disorders; Deontological Ethics; DNA; Ecology; Engineering; Ethical Analysis; Ethical Theory; Ethics; Fetal Tissue Donation; Fetuses; Genetic Engineering; Genetic Intervention; Life; Medicine; Newborns; Organ Donation; Philosophy; Physician Patient Relationship; Prolongation of Life; Quality of Life; Recombinant DNA Research; Reproductive Technologies; Research; Risk; Science; Selective Abortion; Sanctity of Life; Slippery Slope Argument; Tissue Donation; Utilitarianism; Value of Life; Wedge Argument;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Almond, Brenda; Ulanowsky, Carole (1990)Testing women of childbearing age for HIV infection and disclosure of HIV status should be examined from three interlocking perspectives -- women's personal concerns, the interests of caregivers, and those of the community. ...