Development of a Hospital Ethics Committee: Lessons From Five Years of Case Consultations
Andereck, William S.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics. 1992 Winter; 1(1): 41-50.
The development and consultation experience of an ethics committee in an urban community hospital has been presented, and various approaches to case consultation have been considered. Our committee has concentrated on the clinical evaluation model. As expected, most consultations have centered on issues of withdrawing or limiting medical care. Most patients evaluated have been unable to clearly express their wishes concerning further treatments, highlighting the need for promoting advance directives. When resorting to substituted judgment, our committee has supported continued care in a majority of cases. Limitation of the consultation process to the attending physician has, in our experience, actually served to increase the credibility of the committee and has promoted acceptance of its recommendations. The committee's most useful function seems to be in assisting physicians and their patients in defining realistic goals and limitations of treatment. Within this context, the coming decade may find ethics committees concerned less with promoting the autonomous wishes of individual patients than with defining the limits of that autonomy against the competing demands of the larger society. Such a shift should be approached with caution.
Advance Directives; Allowing to Die; Autonomy; Case Studies; Clinical Ethics; Clinical Ethics Committees; Competence; Consent; Consultation; Decision Making; Economics; Ethicists; Ethics; Ethics Committees; Evaluation; Goals; Hospitals; Informed Consent; Life; Patients; Physicians; Prognosis; Program Descriptions; Quality of Life; Resource Allocation; Substituted Judgment; Withholding Treatment;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Andereck, William S. (1992)The development and consultation experience of an ethics committee in an urban community hospital has been presented, and various approaches to case consultation have been considered. Our committee has concentrated on ...
Should Hospital Policy Require Consent for Practicing Invasive Procedures on Cadavers? the Arguments, Conclusions, and Lessons From One Ethics Committee's Deliberations Perkins, Henry S.; Gordon, Anna M. (1994)In July 1989, nurses at a San Antonio, Texas, hospital were troubled to discover that an intern had practiced endotracheal intubation on a cadaver without prior permission from the patient or his family. The nurses ...