Treatment Decisions for Terminally Ill Patients: Physicians' Legal Defensiveness and Knowledge of Medical Law
McCrary, S. Van
Swanson, Jeffrey W.
Perkins, Henry S.
Winslade, William J.
Law, Medicine and Health Care. 1992 Winter; 20(4): 364-376.
In this study, we investigated physicians' attitudes, knowledge, and reported practices regarding the effects of perceived legal constraints on the abatement of life-sustaining treatment from patients who are clearly dying. A factor in assessing these issues is the concept of defensive medicine -- that is the perception that doctors are being forced to order every possible laboratory test and second opinion, or to continue providing non-beneficial life-sustaining treatment, solely to protect themselves from future legal claims. This perception appears widespread among practicing physicians. However, we believe that defensive medicine represents only part of a complex constellation of factors that comprise physicians' reluctance to abate treatment. This phenomenon encompasses medical, legal, social, psychological, and spiritual factors interacting in ways that are not fully understood. We remain cognizant of the potential impact of all these factors. For purposes of this article, however, we have chosen to focus on legal and psychological aspects of physicians' reluctance to abate treatment and the corresponding ethical implications.
Allowing to Die; Attitudes; Competence; Consent; Decision Making; Doctors; Evaluation; Evaluation Studies; Family Members; Government; Government Regulation; Health; Knowledge; Law; Legal Aspects; Legal Liability; Life; Liability; Malpractice; Medicine; Patients; Physicians; Prolongation of Life; Regulation; Risk; Science; Social Impact; Survey; Terminal Care; Terminally Ill; Third Party Consent; Treatment Refusal; Withholding Treatment;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Physicians' Legal Defensiveness in End-of-Life Treatment Decisions: Comparing Attitudes and Knowledge in States With Different Laws McCrary, S. Van; Swanson, Jeffrey W.; Coulehan, Jack; Faber-Langendoen, K.; Olick, Robert S.; Belling, Catherine (2006-03)
McCrary, S. Van; Swanson, Jeffrey W.; Youngner, Stuart J.; Perkins, Henry S.; Winslade, William J. (1994)We believe that data indicating the level of agreement among physicians on the issue of futility will advance the debate regarding the appropriateness of physicians' acting as unilateral arbiters of futility. Therefore, ...