United States and Canadian Approaches to Justice in Health Care: A Comparative Analysis of Health Care Systems and Values
Jecker, Nancy S.
Meslin, Eric M.
Theoretical Medicine. 1994 Jun; 15(2): 181-200.
The purpose of this study is to compare and contrast the basic ethical values underpinning national health care policies in the United States and Canada. We use the framework of ethical theory to name and elaborate ethical values and to facilitate moral reflection about health care reform. Section one describes historical and contemporary social contract theories and clarifies the ethical values associated with them. Sections two and three show that health care debates and health care systems in both countries reflect the values of this tradition; however, each nation interprets the tradition differently. In the U.S., standards of justice for health care are conceived as a voluntary agreement reached by self-interested parties. Canadians, by contrast, interpret the same justice tradition as placing greater emphasis on concern for others and for the community. The final section draws out the implications of these differences for future U.S. and Canadian health care reforms.
Common Good; Comparative Studies; Contracts; Economics; Ethical Theory; Financial Support; Freedom; Government; Government Financing; Health; Health Care; Health Care Delivery; Health Care Reform; Health Insurance; Indigents; Insurance; International Aspects; Justice; National Health Insurance; Philosophy; Policy Analysis; Politics; Public Opinion; Resource Allocation; Rights; Standards; Trends; Values;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.