When Families Request That `Everything Possible' Be Done
Jecker, Nancy S.
Schneiderman, Lawrence J.
Journal of Medicine and Philosophy. 1995 Apr; 20(2): 146-163.
The paper explores the ethical and psychological issues that arise when family members request that "everything possible" be done for a particular patient. The paper first illustrates this phenomenon by reviewing the well known case of Helga Wanglie. We proceed to argue that in Wanglie and similar cases family members may request futile treatments as a means of conveying that (1) the loss of the patient is tantamount to losing a part of themselves; (2) the patient should not be abandoned or disvalued in any way; or (3) the patient is owed special obligations by virtue of the special relationship in which the family and the patient stand. We maintain that families can best express these important messages by caring for patients, rather than by making requests for futile interventions. Likewise, when life-sustaining measures are futile, health providers can best fulfill their professional obligations by assuring patients' dignity and comfort, rather than by applying futile interventions.
Allowing to Die; Autonomy; Caring; Communication; Family Members; Family Relationship; Futility; Goals; Health; Legal Aspects; Life; Love; Medicine; Moral Obligations; Motivation; Paternalism; Patients; Patients' Rights; Persistent Vegetative State; Physician Patient Relationship; Physician's Role; Physicians; Prolongation of Life; Refusal to Treat; Rights; Sociology; Sociology of Medicine; Terminal Care; Terminally Ill; Ventilators; Withholding Treatment;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Schneiderman, Lawrence J.; Jecker, Nancy S.; Rozance, Christine; Klotzko, Arlene Judith; Friedl, Birgit (1995)A referral was made to our Cardiac Transplant Program for a patient who was in the New Jersey Prison System. The Medical Director of the New Jersey Department of Corrections called regarding a 39-year-old inmate who was being ...
Schneiderman, Lawrence J.; Jecker, Nancy S.; Jonsen, Albert R. (1996-10-15)Six years ago, we proposed a patient benefit-centered definition of medical futility that included both quantitative and qualitative components. We distinguished between an effect of a treatment that is limited to some ...