Access to Adult Liver Transplantation in Canada: A Survey and Ethical Analysis
Mullen, Michelle A.
Singer, Peter A.
Canadian Medical Association Journal. 1996 Feb 1; 154(3): 337-342.
OBJECTIVES: To describe the substantive and procedural criteria used for placing patients on the waiting list for liver transplantation and for allocating available livers to patients on the waiting list; to identify principal decision-makers and the main factors limiting liver transplantation in Canada; and to examine how closely cadaveric liver allocation resembles theoretic models of source allocation. DESIGN: Mailed survey. PARTICIPANTS: Medical directors of all seven Canadian adult liver transplantation centres, or their designates. Six of the questionnaires were completed. OUTCOME MEASURES: Relative importance of substantive and procedural criteria used to place patients in the waiting list for liver transplantation and to allocate available livers. Identification of principal decision-makers and main limiting factors to adult liver transplantation. RESULTS: Alcoholism, drug addiction, HIV positivity, primary liver cancer, noncompliance and hepatitis B were the most important criteria that had a negative influence on decisions to place patients on the waiting list for liver transplantation. Severity of disease and urgency were the most important criteria used for selecting patients on the waiting list for transplantation. Criteria that were inconsistent across the centres included social support (for deciding who is placed on the waiting list) and length of time on the waiting list (for deciding who is selected from the list). Although a variety of people were reported as being involved in these decisions, virtually all were reported to be health to be health care professionals. Thirty-seven patients died while waiting for liver transplantation in 1991; the scarcity of cadaveric livers was the main limiting factor. CONCLUSIONS: Criteria for resource allocation decisions regarding liver transplantation are generally consistent among the centres across Canada, although some important inconsistencies remain. Because patients die while on the waiting list and because the primary limiting factor is organ supply, increased organ acquisition efforts are needed.
Addiction; Age Factors; Alcohol Abuse; Cancer; Decision Making; Diagnosis; Disease; Ethical Analysis; Health; Health Care; Hepatitis; HIV Seropositivity; Hospitals; Institutional Policies; Illness; Justice; Livers; Liver Transplantation; Organ Transplantation; Patient Care; Patient Care Team; Patients; Prognosis; Questionnaires; Resource Allocation; Scarcity; Selection for Treatment; Socioeconomic Factors; Standards; Survey; Tissue Transplantation; Transplantation;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Mullen, Michelle A.; Kohut, Nitsa; Sam, Mehran; Blendis, Laurie; Singer, Peter A. (1996-02-01)
The Incommensurability of Research Risks and Benefits: Practical Help for Research Ethics Committees Martin, Douglas K.; Meslin, Eric M.; Kohut, Nitsa; Singer, Peter A. (1995-03)
Stability of Treatment Preferences: Although Most Preferences Do Not Change, Most People Change Some of Their Preferences Kohut, Nitsa; Sam, Mehran; O'Rourke, Keith; MacFadden, Douglas K.; Salit, Irving; Singer, Peter A. (1997)