Therapeutic Discourse Among Nurses and Physicians in Controlled Clinical Trials
Instone, Susan L.
Gilbert, Tari L.
Nursing Ethics 2008 November; 15(6): 803-812
An ethnographic field study about the informed consent process in investigational drug trials for seriously ill persons with hepatitis C suggests that nurses and physicians referred to these trials as giving treatment, even though they involved placebos. Interview data and informed consent documents contained frequent references to the term 'treatment trial' or 'treatment'. Although these findings were unexpected and not the original focus of our study, we consider them in the light of an extensive literature on the 'therapeutic misconception' that has been described among physicians and patients with AIDS and other serious illnesses. We also suggest that certain organizational and professional characteristics of nursing and medicine reinforce this tendency to refer to the trials as treatment. Implications for further research are provided.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Mueller, Mary-Rose (1997)
Clinical, Technical, and Social Contingencies and the Decisions of Adults With HIV/AIDS to Enroll in Clinical Trials Mueller, Mary-Rose (2004-05)
Involvement and (Potential) Influence of Care Providers in the Enlistment Phase of the Informed Consent Process: The Case of AIDS Clinical Trials Mueller, Mary-Rose (2004-01)This article draws on ethnographic field data collected during an investigation of the informed consent process and AIDS clinical trials. It describes the involvement of care providers (physicians, nurse practitioners, ...