Cesarean Delivery on Maternal Request: Can the Ethical Problem Be Solved by the Principlist Approach?
da Frè, Monica
BMC Medical Ethics [electronic] 2008 June 17; 9:11. 8 p. Accessed: http://www.biomedcentral.com/bmcmedethics/1472-6939/9/11 [2008 August 1]
In this article, we use the principlist approach to identify, analyse and attempt to solve the ethical problem raised by a pregnant woman's request for cesarean delivery in absence of medical indications. We use two different types of premises: factual (facts about cesarean delivery and specifically attitudes of obstetricians as derived from the EUROBS European study) and value premises (principles of beneficence and non-maleficence, respect for autonomy and justice). Beneficence/non-maleficence entails physicians' responsibility to minimise harms and maximise benefits. Avoiding its inherent risks makes a prima facie case against cesarean section without medical indication. However, as vaginal delivery can have unintended consequences, there is a need to balance the somewhat dissimilar risks and benefits. The principle of autonomy poses a challenge in case of disagreement between the pregnant woman and the physician. Improved communication aimed to enable better informed choice may overcome some instances of disagreement. The principle of justice prohibits unfair discrimination, and broadly favours optimising resource utilisation. Available evidence supports vaginal birth in uncomplicated term pregnancies as the standard of care. The principlist approach offered a useful framework for ethical analysis of cesarean delivery on maternal request, identified the rights and duties of those involved, and helped reach a conclusion, although conflict at the individual level may remain challenging.
Find in a Library
Full Text from Publisher
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Cuttini, Marina; Habiba, Marwan; Nilstun, Tore; Donfrancesco, Silvia; Garel, Micheline; Arnaud, Catherine; Bleker, Otto; Da Frè, Monica; Gomez, Manuel Marin; Heyl, Wolfgang; Marsal, Karel; Saracci, Rodolfo (2006-11)
Nilstun, Tore; Cuttini, Marina; Saracci, Rodolfo (2001-12)Almost all articles on education in medical ethics present proposals for or describe experiences of teaching students in different health professions. Since experienced staff also need such education, the purpose of this ...
The EURONIC Project: A European Concerted Action on Information to Parents and Ethical Decision-Making in Neonatal Intensive Care Cuttini, Marina; Kaminiski, Monique; Saracci, Rodolfo; deVonderweid, Umberto (1997-10)