Turning the History of Medical Ethics From Its Head Onto Its Feet: A Critical Commentary on Baker and McCullough
Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 2007 March; 17(1): 31-42
The paper provides a critical commentary on the article by Baker and McCullough on Medical Ethic's Appropriation of Moral Philosophy. The author argues that Baker and McCullough offer a more "pragmatic" approach to the history of medical ethics that has the potential to enrich the bioethics field with a greater historical grounding and sound methodology. Their approach can help us to come to a more nuanced understanding about the way in which medical ethics has connected, disconnected, and reconnected with philosophical ideas throughout the centuries. The author points out that Baker and McCullough's model can run the danger of overemphasizing the role of medical ethicists whilst marginalizing the influence of philosophers and of other historical actors and forces. He critically reviews the two case studies on which Baker and McCullough focus and concludes that scholars need to bear in mind the levels of uncertainty and ambivalence that accompany the process of transformation and dissemination of moral values in medicine and medical practice.
Case Studies; Ethicists; Ethics; Medical Ethics; Medicine; Philosophy; Uncertainty; Values; Philosophical Ethics; Bioethics; History of Health Ethics / Bioethics; Sociology of Health Care; Torture and Genocide; Applied and Professional Ethics; Prolongation of Life and Euthanasia; Philosophy of Medicine;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
The Travails and Triumphs of Publishing the First Global History of Medical Ethics. the Crambridge World History of Medical Ethics Examines the Evolution of Medical Ethics From the 12th Century to Today Baker, Robert B.; McCullough, Laurence B. (2009-03)
McCullough, Laurence B. (1999-03)At different times during its history medicine has been laid open to accountability for its scientific and moral quality. This phenonmenon of laying medicine open has sometimes resulted in major turning points in the history ...
McCullough, Laurence B. (1999-03)