Competence by Consequence: Ambiguity and Incoherence in the Law
Medicine and Law: World Association for Medical Law 2006 March; 25(1): 1-12
There is an ambiguity of principle delivered by those legal judgements which have considered the issue of whether the level of patients' decision-making capacity should vary in accordance with the seriousness of risks associated with the procedure subject to decision, particularly in decisions to refuse life-saving treatment. There appears to be support for (1) a risk-related standard of capacity, although some judgements could also be interpreted as (2) a procedural standard, subject to a rigorous standard of evidence of capacity. I argue that a risk-related standard of capacity itself is incoherent. This would lend weight to the second interpretation. However, I argue that the wording of the judgements belies an allegiance to the first interpretation, which is also consistent with how medical practitioners generally view capacity in these situations. I consider the implications of the dissonance between the two ways of interpreting the judgments, and make suggestions aimed at clarifying the issue of risk-related competence for clinicians.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Lizza, John P. (2009-12)This commentary challenges the conclusions reached by Franklin Miller and Robert Truog in their criticism of the President's Council's White Paper, "Controversies in the Determination of Death." I agree with much of Miller ...
Miller, Franklin G.; Brody, Howard (2007-03)The doctrine of clinical equipoise is appealing because it appears to permit physicians to maintain their therapeutic obligation to offer optimal medical care to patients while conducting randomized controlled trials (RCTs). ...
The Incoherence of Determining Death by Neurological Criteria: A Commentary on "Controversies in the Determination of Death", a White Paper by the President's Council on Bioethics Miller, Franklin G.; Truog, Robert D. (2009-06)Traditionally the cessation of breathing and heart beat has marked the passage from life to death. Shortly after death was determined, the body became a cold corpse, suitable for burial or cremation. Two technological ...