Does Informed Consent Exempt Japanese Doctors From Reporting Therapeutic Deaths?
Journal of Medical Ethics 2006 February; 32(2): 114-116
The Japanese Medical Act section 21 states that doctors must report unnatural deaths to the police, even though the term "unnatural death" is not defined by law. However, many doctors are reluctant to report potential therapeutic deaths (PTDs). The Japanese Society of Legal Medicine has submitted guidelines for unnatural death, including PTD. These define a PTD as an unexpected death, the cause of which is unknown, but which is potentially related to medical practice. Such deaths are "reportable" to the coroner in the UK. In this study, we addressed the question of whether physicians would report each of eight hypothetical PTDs. Although the clinical societies (the Japan Society of Internal Medicine and the Japan Surgical Society) declare that doctors must report deaths due to gross negligence, 60% of the participants said that they would not report gross negligence involving an overdose in cases where they had obtained informed consent or had provided an explanation after the death occurred. This can be accounted for by the mistaken belief on the part of the participants that obtaining informed consent exempts Japanese physicians from the duty of reporting PTDs. The attitude of Japanese physicians is caused by the death investigation system, which is designed to discover whether a crime has been committed rather than focusing on the cause of death. Accordingly, the Japanese Government has decided to commission a pilot study from an independent organisation in which medical specialists will investigate PTDs in order to prevent deaths occurring as a result of gross negligence.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Does the Japanese Society for Hygiene Need Its Own Code of Conduct? A Comparison of the Responses of Councilors and Junior Members Based on a Questionnaire Survey Ikeda, Wakaha; Inaba, Yutaka; Takeshita, Tatsuya; Yoshida, Katsumi; Ogoshi, Kumiko; Okamoto, Kazushi (2011-05)The purpose of this study was to compare current awareness of the "On a Code of Conduct for Scientists" (OCCS) among members of the Japanese Society for Hygiene (JSH).
Does Informed Consent Influence Therapeutic Outcome? A Clinical Trial of the Hypnotic Activity of Placebo in Patients Admitted to Hospital Dahan, R.; Caulin, C.; Figea, L.; Kanis, J.A.; Caulin, F.; Segrestaa, J.M. (1986-08-09)
Does Informed Consent Influence Therapeutic Outcome? a Clinical Trial of the Hypnotic Activity of Placebo in Patients Admitted to Hospital Dahan, R.; Caulin, C.; Figea, L.; Kanis, J.A.; Caulin, F.; Segrestaa, J.M. (1986-08-09)To determine whether informed consent requirements affect the outcome of clinical trials, the authors designed a trial to study the effect of a placebo when administered with or without informed consent. Hospitalized patients ...