Compromised Ethical Principles in Randomised Clinical Trials of Distant, Intercessory Prayer
Hobbins, Peter Graeme
Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 2005; 2(3): 142-152
The effects of distant, intercessory prayer on health outcomes have been studied in a range of randomised, blinded clinical trials. However, while seeking the evidentiary status accorded this 'gold standard' methodology, many prayer studies fall short of the requirements of the World Medical Association's Declaration of Helsinki for the ethical conduct of trials involving human subjects. Within a sample of 15 such studies published in the medical literature, many were found to have ignored or waived key ethical precepts, including inadequate standards of care, patient confidentiality and informed consent. Prayer was considered in most studies to pose negligible or no risk to subjects, despite the fact that no clear mechanism of action nor any safety monitoring procedures were described. As a result, many studies did not meet basic ethical standards required of clinical trials of biophysical interventions, making application of their results ethically problematic. If investigators wish their data to adequately inform the use or rejection of intercessory prayer to improve health, these shortcomings should be addressed in future studies.
Clinical Trials; Confidentiality; Consent; Health; Informed Consent; Investigators; Literature; Prayer; Risk; Standards; Religious Ethics; Human Experimentation Policy Guidelines / Institutional Review Boards; Informed Consent or Human Experimentation; Scientific Research Ethics; Research on Special Populations;
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Just Another Drug? A Philosophical Assessment of Randomised Controlled Studies on Intercessory Prayer Turner, D.D. (2006-08)The empirical results from recent randomised controlled studies on remote, intercessory prayer remain mixed. Several studies have, however, appeared in prestigious medical journals, and it is believed by many researchers, ...