Interventions to Improve Research Participants' Understanding in Informed Consent for Research
JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association 2004 October 6; 292(13): 1593-1601
CONTEXT: Available data suggest that prospective research participants may frequently not understand information disclosed to them in the informed consent process. Little is known about how understanding can be improved. OBJECTIVE: To review research on interventions to improve research participants' understanding of information disclosed in the informed consent process. DATA SOURCES AND STUDY SELECTION: A search of MEDLINE was performed using the terms informed consent and clinical research and informed consent and (comprehension or understanding) from 1966 to March 2004 , which included randomized controlled trials, longitudinal trials, and controlled trials with nonrandom allocation that compared the understanding of research participants who had undergone only a standard informed consent process to that of participants who had received an intervention to improve their understanding. A comprehensive bibliography of empirical research on informed consent published in January 1999 was also reviewed, as were personal files and all issues of the journals IRB and Controlled Clinical Trials. DATA EXTRACTION: Study design, quality criteria, population characteristics, interventions, and outcomes for each trial were extracted. The statistical significance of the interventions' effects on understanding were noted, as were mean scores for understanding for each group of each trial. For those trials that measured the secondary outcomes of satisfaction and willingness to enroll, results were also summarized. DATA SYNTHESIS: Thirty studies described 42 trials that met inclusion criteria. Of 12 trials of multimedia interventions, 3 showed significant improvement in understanding. Of 15 trials of enhanced consent forms, 6 showed significant improvement in understanding (all P
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Flory, James; Wendler, David; Emanuel, Ezekiel (2007)
Flory, James H.; Wendler, David; Emanuel, Ezekiel J. (2008)
Post-Trial Access to Tested Interventions: The Views of IRB/REC Chair, Investigators, and Research Participants in a Multinational HIV/AIDS Study Pace, Christine; Grady, Christine; Wendler, David; Bebchuk, Judith D.; Tavel, Jorge A.; McNay, Laura A.; Forster, Heidi P.; Killen, Jack; Emanuel, Ezekiel J. (Espirit Group, 2006-09)