Brief Communication: The Relationship Between Having a Living Will and Dying in Peace
Degenholtz, Howard B.
Arnold, Robert M.
Annals of Internal Medicine 2004 July 20; 141(2): 113-117
Living wills, a type of advance directive, are promoted as a way for patients to document preferences for life-sustaining treatments should they become incompetent. Previous research, however, has found that these documents do not guide decision making in the hospital. OBJECTIVE: To test the hypothesis that people with living wills are less likely to die in a hospital than in their residence before death. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of data from a nationally representative longitudinal study. SETTING: Publicly available data from the Asset and Health Dynamics Among the Oldest Old (AHEAD) study. PATIENTS: People older than 70 years of age living in the community in 1993 who died between 1993 and 1995. MEASUREMENTS: Self-report and proxy informant interviews conducted in 1993 and 1995. RESULTS: Having a living will was associated with lower probability of dying in a hospital for nursing home residents and people living in the community. For people living in the community, the probability of in-hospital death decreased from 0.65 (95% CI, 0.58 to 0.71) to 0.52 (CI, 0.42 to 0.62). For people living in nursing homes, the probability of in-hospital death decreased from 0.35 (CI, 0.23 to 0.49) to 0.13 (CI, 0.07 to 0.22). LIMITATIONS: Retrospective survey data do not contain detailed clinical information on whether the living will was consulted. CONCLUSION: Living wills are associated with dying in place rather than in a hospital. This implies that previous research examining only people who died in a hospital suffers from selection bias. During advance care planning, physicians should discuss patients' preferences for location of death.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Degenholtz, Howard B.; Arnold, Robert A.; Meisel, Alan; Lave, Judith R. (2002-02)
Annas, George J.; Armstrong, Paul W.; Arnold, Bob; Asch, Adrienne; Botkin, Jeffrey R.; Boyajian, Jane; Caplan, Arthur; Capron, Alexander M.; Churchill, Larry R.; Derse, Arthur R.; Elias, Sherman; Fleischman, Alan R.; Forrow, Lachlan; Glantz, Leonard; Glick, Shimon; Goodman, Kenneth W.; Greenlaw, Jane L.; Grodin, Michael A.; Harvey, John Collins; Howe, Edmund G.; Jennings, Bruce; Jonsen, Al; Katz, Jay; Khushf, George; King, Nancy M.P.; King, Patricia A.; Larkin, Gregory L.; Lo, Bernard; Mariner, Wendy K.; Mayo, Thomas W.; McGee, Ellen; McGee, Glenn; Miles, Steve; Moreno, Jonathan D.; Nelson, Robert M.; Nixon, Lois LaCivita; Olick, Robert S.; Pentz, Rebecca D.; Peterson, Lynn; Polak, Joseph; Post, Stephen G.; Reich, Warren T.; Rothman, David J.; Sheldon, Mark; Shuster, Evelyne; Sulmasy, Daniel P.; White, W.D.; Wolf, Susan M.; Zoloth- Dorfman, Laurie (1996-11-12)