Importance of Patient Pressure and Perceived Pressure and Perceived Medical Need for Investigations, Referral, and Prescribing in Primary Care: Nested Observational Study
BMJ: British Medical Journal 2004 February 21; 328(7437): 444- 446
OBJECTIVE: To assess how pressures from patients on doctors in the consultation contribute to referral and investigation. DESIGN: Observational study nested within a randomised controlled trial. SETTING: Five general practices in three settings in the United Kingdom. PARTICIPANTS: 847 consecutive patients, aged 16-80 years. MAIN OUTCOMES MEASURES: Patient preferences and doctors' perception of patient pressure and medical need. RESULTS: Perceived medical need was the strongest independent predictor of all behaviours and confounded all other predictors. The doctors thought, however, there was no or only a slight indication for medical need among a significant minority of those who were examined (89/580, 15%), received a prescription (74/394, 19%), or were referred (27/125, 22%) and almost half of those investigated (99/216, 46%). After controlling for patient preference, medical need, and clustering by doctor, doctors' perceptions of patient pressure were strongly associated with prescribing (adjusted odds ratio 2.87, 95% confidence interval 1.16 to 7.08) and even more strongly associated with examination (4.38, 1.24 to 15.5), referral (10.72, 2.08 to 55.3), and investigation (3.18, 1.31 to 7.70). In all cases, doctors' perception of patient pressure was a stronger predictor than patients' preferences. Controlling for randomisation group, mean consultation time, or patient variables did not alter estimates or inferences. CONCLUSIONS: Doctors' behaviour in the consultation is most strongly associated with perceived medical need of the patient, which strongly confounds other predictors. However, a significant minority of examining, prescribing, and referral, and almost half of investigations, are still thought by the doctor to be slightly needed or not needed at all, and perceived patient pressure is a strong independent predictor of all doctor behaviours. To limit unnecessary resource use and iatrogenesis, when management decisions are not thought to be medically needed, doctors need to directly ask patients about their expectations.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Randomised Controlled Trial of Effect of Leaflets to Empower Patients in Consultations in Primary Care Little, Paul; Dorward, Martina; Warner, Greg; Moore, Michael; Stephens, Katharine; Senior, Jane; Kendrick, Tony (2004-02-21)OBJECTIVE: To assess the impact of leaflets encouraging patients to raise concerns and to discuss symptoms or other health related issues in the consultation. DESIGN: Randomised controlled trial. SETTING: Five general ...
Preferences of Patients for Patient Centred Approach to Consultation in Primary Care: Observational Study Little, Paul; Everitt, Hazel; Williamson, Ian; Warner, Greg; Moore, Michael; Gould, Clare; Ferrier, Kate; Payne, Sheila (2001-02-24)
Observational Study of Effect of Patient Centredness and Positive Approach on Outcomes of General Practice Consultations Little, Paul; Everitt, Hazel; Williamson, Ian; Warner, Greg; Moore, Michael; Gould, Clare; Ferrier, Kate; Payne, Sheila (2001-10-20)